Skip to content
Ceremonial Key
Search

Search the register

History of the Key to the City: Origins and Tradition

The key to the city is usually traced to medieval walled towns whose gates were locked at night, but that explanation is commonly told, not documented by the sources we opened. New York City's own pages date its first key to 1702 and say giving keys became customary by the mid-1800s. No source we opened names a first recipient anywhere.

Weathered stone gateway with closed wooden doors and a lit lantern at dusk
Weathered stone gateway with closed wooden doors and a lit lantern at dusk

Part of the series: Key to the City: What It Is, Who Gives It and Why

The key to the city has a famous origin story and a thin paper trail. This page separates the two. For the overview of the honor itself, see our key to the city guide. Here we cover only what sources say about where the tradition came from.

Finding-aid note: the sources cited here were consulted on 2026-11-17 and set beside the statements above.

The commonly told origin: locked gates in walled towns

The story most often repeated is that medieval cities were surrounded by walls, their gates were locked at night, and a key meant its holder could come and go freely. Boston.com tells it this way, saying the tradition “dates back to medieval times,” and credits the account to the Joukowsky Institute for Archaeology & the Ancient World at Brown University. The article gives no specific medieval dates, and we could not open the institute’s own page, so we pass the account along as commonly told, attributed to the sources that tell it.

Treat it as a plausible explanation of why the object is a key, not as a documented line from a gate keeper to a modern mayor. Nothing we opened shows a particular gate key given to a particular honored person.

An iron key on a stone threshold in front of a closed wooden town gate

What a city’s own pages say: New York

New York City’s Mayor’s Office is the clearest primary source we opened. Its press releases about key presentations carry the same history paragraph. They say the Key to the City of New York was first awarded in 1702 by Mayor Phillip French, and the release for the Rangel presentation ties that first award to Viscount Edward Cornbury, then governor of New York and New Jersey, and to the Freedom of the City. They add that by the mid-1800s it had become customary to give the key as a symbol of the city’s wish that a guest feel free to come and go at will.

Two cautions. First, this is the city describing its own tradition, in a press release, not an archive record. Second, it is a claim about New York. It does not say New York gave the first key anywhere. For how New York handles the honor today, see our New York page.

Keys in the early 1900s: Pittsburgh

WESA’s reporting on Pittsburgh gives some of the best dated detail we found. The city’s archivist, Charles Succop, said the tradition has lasted at least a century and showed two metal key molds, about three inches long, possibly from the turn of the century; one reads “Pittsburgh: Gateway to the West.” The same article reports:

  • A 1911 visit in which a city solicitor, representing the mayor, presented a key to a group of actors.
  • Mayor Charles Kline giving Amelia Earhart a golden key during a two-hour stop in July 1928.
  • A 1944 war bond drive in which the top buyer was promised “permanent possession of a gold key to the city.”

The article is also candid that Pittsburgh’s records of recipients are incomplete. That is typical, and it is why a recipient list for any city should be read as partial.

A modern ceremonial key in the record: Los Angeles

The Smithsonian’s National Air and Space Museum holds a Key to the City of Los Angeles presented to Dr. Sally K. Ride by Mayor Tom Bradley in October 1984, listed as a gift of Tam O’Shaughnessy. A museum record is not a city policy, but it is a dated, institutional document of a presentation. See the Los Angeles page for what the city itself publishes.

Timeline of what we could document

Date What the source says Source type
1702 New York says its first key was awarded by Mayor Phillip French City press release
Mid-1800s New York says giving the key became customary City press release
Around 1900 Pittsburgh archivist shows two key molds, possibly from the turn of the century News report quoting a city archivist
1928 Earhart given a golden key during a stop in Pittsburgh News report
1944 Pittsburgh war bond drive offers a gold key to the top buyer News report
October 1984 Los Angeles key presented to Sally Ride Museum record

What is unknown or disputed

  • The first key anywhere. No source we opened names it. Claims that a famous person received “the first” key are common online; we do not repeat them without an opened primary source.
  • The link to medieval gates. Commonly told, not documented in the pages we opened.
  • Why the practice spread across US cities. We found no source that traces it, so we do not offer a theory.
  • Ancient or foreign roots. Some websites link the key to ancient Rome or to the English Freedom of the City. We did not open a reliable source for those links, so they stay out. The Freedom of the City is a separate honor; see the civic honors comparison.

How to research a city’s history yourself

  1. Search the city’s own site for “key to the city”, plus the words ceremonial, honors or protocol.
  2. Ask the city clerk or archivist whether a register of keys or honors exists. Give the years you care about.
  3. Search the city newspaper’s own archive. Some libraries offer access to digitized runs.
  4. Try the Library of Congress Chronicling America collection for pre-1964 newspapers.
  5. Note the date and the paper for every claim. A quote with a date and a named official is worth ten unsourced lists.
  6. Be skeptical of lists of recipients without citations. Our facts explorer includes only entries we could source, which is why it is short.

Common mistakes when writing about the history

  • Stating “the first key to the city was given to…” with no archive reference.
  • Treating a city press release as proof of an event far in the past.
  • Mixing up the key, the Freedom of the City and a proclamation. They are different honors.
  • Copying a recipient list from a wiki without checking the primary source.

If you find a dated, citable record we missed, send it through our contact page and we will review it.

Answers to common questions

Where did the key to the city come from?

The commonly told story is that medieval walled towns locked their gates at night, so a key meant trusted freedom to come and go. Boston.com repeats that account and credits it to Brown University's Joukowsky Institute, without giving dates. New York City's own pages give a documented starting point for its key: 1702. We found no source that settles the origin for every city.

Were keys to the city once real keys to city gates?

That is how the legend goes, and it is plausible for walled towns, but we did not open a primary source that shows a specific gate key being handed to a specific person. We therefore treat it as a commonly told explanation. What we can document is that modern keys are symbolic. WESA's Pittsburgh reporting, for example, says the key does not unlock anything.

When was the first key to the city given?

Not documented in the sources we opened. New York City says its first key was awarded in 1702 by Mayor Phillip French, but that is a claim about New York, not about the first key anywhere. Pittsburgh's archivist says its tradition spans at least a century. No source we opened names a first recipient or a first city, so we do not.

Why a key and not a medal?

No source we opened answers this directly. New York City's pages say the key came to symbolize a guest's freedom to come and go at will, which fits the gate story and explains the object's shape. A key says you are welcome, while a medal says you achieved something. Cities may choose either, and many give both a key and a certificate.

Where can I find records of past keys?

Start with the city itself: the mayor's office, the city clerk and any city archivist or archives page. Then search a newspaper's own archive or the Library of Congress Chronicling America collection for the city and the words key to the city. Expect gaps: Pittsburgh's archivist says its list of recipients is incomplete, and other cities may have no list at all.

Further reading

  1. New York City Mayor's Office: Mayor Adams awards Key to the City of New York to Sean Combs (September 2023) (nyc.gov)
  2. New York City Mayor's Office: Mayor Adams posthumously awards Key to the City to Charles B. Rangel (June 2025) (nyc.gov)
  3. Boston.com: What does it mean to have a key to the city? (September 11, 2026) (boston.com)
  4. WESA: What does it mean to get the key to Pittsburgh? (June 28, 2023) (wesanews.org)
  5. Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum: Key, City of Los Angeles, Sally Ride (airandspace.si.edu)

Related reading